Health Matters
Printing is not available for Health Matters content.
Subscribers can read every article in full at health-matters.io.

Lump-Sum Payouts for Medical Negligence Face a Constitutional Court Challenge From the State

Learn why the state wants the Constitutional Court to allow treatment instead of lump-sum payouts in medical negligence cases, and why critics object.
Lump-Sum Payouts for Medical Negligence Face a Constitutional Court Challenge From the State
Image | Nadzeya Haroshka | iStock/2174681925

The government has asked the Constitutional Court to allow provinces to provide treatment instead of lump-sum payouts when patients are harmed through medical negligence. It argues that the current system is draining provincial health budgets. Total medico-legal claims exceed R50bn as a result.

The Eastern Cape, Gauteng and Limpopo account for 74% of claims. The Eastern Cape, which faces nearly R20bn in claims, is leading the challenge. Moreover, it has the support of the national health department and all eight other provinces.

Continue reading with a Health Matters subscription

Subscribers read every article in full, receive the daily briefing and have access to the complete archive.

SubscribeLog in

Not ready to subscribe? Get Health Matters Weekly free: the week’s top healthcare headlines every Friday.

More from Health Matters

15.11.2026

Understand the challenges of mental health underwriting in life insurance and why insurers must adapt to new realities.

13.11.2026

Aspen share buybacks total R2.43bn as the Ovestin sale releases capital. Explore the earnings outlook and concerns over losing a high-margin product.

13.11.2026

Life Healthcare's trading statement reveals higher normalised earnings, lower HEPS and the impact of a scheme under curatorship.